Home / Thinking Putty Best Sellers
Refined By

Shop by Color

Texture + Size

Collections

Effects

Thinking Putty Best Sellers

Shop Thinking Putty Bestsellers

New to Thinking Putty® or hoping to expand your collection with the best of the best? Look no further! We've collected our all-time best sellers into a collection of products every Crazy Aaron's® fan will love.
super scarab
Quick view
Super Scarab | Illusions Thinking Putty

$ 14.00

Crazy Aaron's Puttyworld Liquid Glass | Crystal Clear Thinking Putty
Quick view
Liquid Glass | Crystal Clear Thinking Putty

$ 14.00

Holographic Mixed By Me Kit
Quick view
Holographic Mixed By Me Kit

$ 20.00

Crazy Aaron's Puttyworld Amethyst Blush | Hypercolor Thinking Putty
Quick view
Amethyst Blush | Hypercolor Thinking Putty

$ 11.00

Tidal Wave | Magnetic Thinking Putty
Quick view
Tidal Wave | Magnetic Thinking Putty

$ 15.00

Crazy Aaron's Puttyworld Gold Rush | Magnetic Thinking Putty
Quick view
Gold Rush | Magnetic Thinking Putty

$ 15.00

MINI 2018 Spring Thinking Putty Collection
Quick view
MINI 2018 Spring Thinking Putty Collection

$ 10.00

MEGA Super Lava | Illusions Thinking Putty
Quick view
MEGA Super Lava | Illusions Thinking Putty

$ 50.00

Crazy Aaron's Puttyworld Ceylon Sapphire | Precious Thinking Putty
Quick view
Ceylon Sapphire | Precious Thinking Putty

$ 10.00

Foxfire | Phantom Thinking Putty
Quick view
Foxfire | Phantom Thinking Putty

$ 15.00

Crazy Aaron's Puttyworld Teal | Electric Thinking Putty
Quick view
Teal | Electric Thinking Putty

$ 10.00

Shop Star Dust Thinking Putty from Crazy Aaron's Puttyworld
Quick view
Star Dust | Cosmic Thinking Putty

$ 15.00

Loading...
Error
 

is added to your shopping cart.

is added to your wish list.

Close